Knuckles # 4247 --- 1999 --- 1 of a Kind Rewarding Limited Production Invaluable U.S. Factory / Canadian Tush Tags Written in English and French ( Very Scarce ) --- Factory Oddities / Unique Features PE 1st Edition --- Multiple Tag Errors --- Brand New -- Iconic Original --- MwmtMq NOTE!! Knowing that exclusivity and uniqueness of a limited stock item always attach a premium to its value. And that Beanie Babies with errors can be much more valuable than ones with perfectly printed tags. Without an Existing Identical listing to compare it to: According to Microsoft's A.I. What makes Ty Dual Tush Tagged Knuckles with Factory Oddities and Multiple Errors so Valuable Ty Knuckles with Dual Tush Tags, Factory Oddities, and Multiple Errors is prized for its extreme rarity, layered production quirks, and collector appeal tied to provenance and exclusivity. Here’s a breakdown of what drives its value: ? Key Rarity Drivers Dual Tush Tags (U.S. + Canadian): Knuckles with both English and French tush tags is exceptionally rare. These dual tags reflect cross-border production quirks and compliance labeling, often linked to limited regional releases. Dual-tagged Beanies can command 10–50% higher prices than single-tag counterparts. Factory Oddities: Includes mismatched tags, unusual stitching, pellet inconsistencies, or tag placement anomalies. These quirks are often unintentional and undocumented, making them highly desirable to collectors who value authenticity and production history. Multiple Tag Errors: Examples include misspellings, extra spaces in poems, incorrect birth dates, or formatting inconsistencies. While some errors (like “ii” or “surface” typos) are common and not inherently valuable, Knuckles-specific errors paired with dual tags and oddities elevate its status. Errors are most valuable when they’re unique to a limited production run or appear on a Beanie with other rare traits. ?? Tag Significance Hang Tag Tush Tag Generations: The generation and condition of both tags are crucial. A mint 4th or 5th gen swing tag with a dual tush tag setup can dramatically increase value. Tags in pristine condition (MWMTMQ: Mint With Mint Tags, Museum Quality) are essential for top-tier valuation. Retirement Status: Knuckles was retired in 1999, adding scarcity and long-term collector interest. ? Market Appeal Narrative Rarity: Knuckles is often marketed as “iconic” due to its layered oddities, making it a centerpiece in themed displays or rarity-focused trios. Sellers emphasize exclusivity, sometimes inflating value through storytelling and strategic listings. Condition Provenance: Beanies with verified provenance, especially those sourced from early factory runs or promotional releases, are more desirable. Mint condition with verified oddities and dual tags can push prices Over $1,000 + range depending on demand. These factors create a sense of rarity and exclusivity, driving up demand and prices in the collector’s market. Making this Mint Most Valuable Distinctive Limited Production Dual U.S. / Canadian Tush Tagged Knuckles with Factory .Oddities / Unique Features and Multiple Tag Errors a Serious Collector’s Item whose Future Selling Price will only continue to Rise! It’s not just a Beanie—it’s a Historical Artifact in Plush Form from the peak of Ty’s collectible craze! Original Owner / Iconic Original / Mint condition 1 of a Kind Most valuable (Incorrect Stitching resulting in Offset / Uneven Eyes with the Right Eye being Higher than the Left One combined with a Crooked Nose / Uneven Nostrils (See Photo # 2 Above) embellished with Invaluable Dual U.S. Factory / Canadian Tush Tags printed in both English and French ( Very Scarce ) ULTRA RARE Most Valuable Factories Oddities / Unique Features ULTRA RARE Most Valuable Factory Tag oddity (Alpha Numeric Birth Date I.E. An actual Month, Day, and Year Spelled out March 25 1999 used only on 1st Editions See Photo # 2 Above) ULTRA RARE No style number on inside of Swing tag ULTRA RARE Xtra Space between Why and the ! in the poem on the Swing Tag ULTRA RARE Xtra Space between pie and the ! in the poem on the Swing Tag ULTRA RARE Oakbrook Misspelled on both tags should be Oak Brook ULTRA RARE i999 TY INC., All Caps on U.S. Tush Tag ULTRA RARE The comma after INC., on the U.S. Tush Tag should not be there Flat Hologram Tush Tag Environ Safe PE Pellets REG NO PA 1965(KR) Tush Tag Designations which add to its Rarity This Fabulous Mint Most Valuable Iconic Original Limited Production Dual Tush Tagged Collectors Gem was stored from the day of purchase was NEVER played with or mishandled. Investment Quality! And to help ensure its INCREASING Future Selling Price, this Prized Knuckles comes with both plastic Swing and Internal Tush tag protectors!