Paul ---1999 --- No Style # --- 1 of a Kind Distinctive Limited Production ( Only Made for 6 Months ) Invaluable Dual U.S. / Canadian Tush Tags written in English and French ( Very Scarce ) --- Factory Oddities / Unique Features --- Multiple Tag Errors --- New --- Iconic Original --- MwmtMq NOTE!! Knowing that exclusivity and uniqueness of a limited stock item always attach a premium to its value. And that Beanie Babies with errors can be much more valuable than ones with perfectly printed tags without an Existing Identical listing to compare it to: According to Microsoft's A.I. Ty Paul with Dual Tush Tags, Factory Oddities, and Multiple Errors is considered highly valuable due to its extreme rarity, production quirks, and collector demand. Here’s a breakdown of what drives its value: ? Key Rarity Factors Dual Tush Tags (U.S. and Canadian): These are written in both English and French, meeting bilingual labeling requirements. This dual-tag configuration is very scarce and typically found only on select Beanie Babies produced for a short time. Limited Production Window: Paul was only manufactured for about six months in 1999 before retirement, making it one of the shortest production runs in Ty’s lineup. No Style Number: The absence of a style number on the swing tag is an unusual omission that adds to its uniqueness. ? Factory Oddities Tag Errors PE Pellets: While not inherently rare, the use of PE pellets in combination with other oddities can signal a transitional or late-run version. Tag Errors: Examples include: A comma after “INC.” on the tush tag (which shouldn’t be there) Misaligned or offset printing Inconsistent birth dates between swing and tush tags Unique Stitching or Eye Placement: Some versions show uneven eye alignment or stitching quirks, which are considered factory oddities that increase value. ? Cultural Emotional Resonance Tribute to Paul McCartney: The character’s name and tag poem referencing a tambourine and submarine evoke Beatles imagery, adding emotional and pop culture appeal. Narrative Potential: Paul’s layered quirks and tribute theme make it ideal for storytelling displays—especially when paired with other music-themed or error-tagged Beanies. ? Market Value Investment Potential High Asking Prices: Listings for mint-condition Paul with dual tush tags and errors range from $2,500 to $5,000 depending on condition and tag configuration. Collector Demand: Dual-tagged Beanies with errors can command 10–50% more than their single-tagged counterparts. Future Appreciation: Because of its rarity and layered appeal, Paul is considered a strong candidate for long-term value growth. These factors create a sense of Rarity and Exclusivity, driving up demand and prices in the collector’s market. Making this Mint Most Valuable Iconic Original Limited Production Dual U.S / Canadian Tush tagged Paul with Factory Oddities / Unique Features and Multiple Tag Errors a Serious Collectors Item whose Future Selling Price will only continue to Rise! Original Owner / Iconic Original/ Mint Condition 1 of a Kind Most Valuable factory Oddities / Unique Features ( Incorrect Stitching resulting in Offset Uneven Eyes The Right Eye is Higher than the Left One combined with Uneven Tusks with the Right One Being Longer than the Left One See Photo # 1 Above ) and Embellished with Invaluable Dual U.S. / Canadian Tush Tags ( written in English and French Very Scarce ) ULTRA RARE Most Valuable Factory Tag Oddity ( Alpha Numeric Birth Date I.E. An actual Month Day and Year Birth Date Spelled Out as February 23 1999 Only Used On 1st Editions See Photo # 3 Above ) ULTRA RARE Most Valuable Factory Oddity / Unique Feature # 2 ( TY's Red Heart Logo is Clearly Visible on the back of the U.S. Tush Tag see photo 7 above ) ULTRA RARE No Style # on the Swing Tag ULTRA RARE Oakbrook Misspelled should be Oak Brook ULTRA RARE Xtra space between land and the ! in the poem on the Swing Tag ULTRA RARE TY INC 1999., All Caps ULTRA RARE The Comma after INC. on the Tush tag should not be there Environ Safe Pellets REG NO PA 1965 (KR ) Designations on the U.S. Tush Tag Which add to its Rarity This Fabulous Mint Most Valuable Iconic Original Limited Production Dual Tush tagged Collector’s Gem was stored from the day of purchase was NEVER played with or mishandled. Investment Quality! And To help ensure its INCREASING Future Selling Price this Prized Paul comes with both plastic Swing and Tush tag protectors.